Compare ice cream tubs in New Zealand at Canstar Blue. Much Moore, Ben & Jerry’s, Cadbury, Countdown Signature Range, Countdown Select, Deep South, Häagen-Dazs, Kapiti, Killinchy Gold, Pams and Tip Top were compared on Overall Satisfaction, Packaging Appeal, Taste, Value for Money, Variety/Range.
See our Ratings Methodology.
Much Moore rated number one for customer satisfaction
I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! Yes, whatever the season – sunshine or snow – it’s hard to resist the temptation of the sweet treat. According to the NZ Ice Cream Manufacturers Association, as a country, each year we consume the equivalent of 23 litres of ice cream per person.
While a lot of that is licked up while out enjoying the great Kiwi summer, most is consumed at home, bought in tubs from supermarkets and convenience stores. According to Canstar’s latest research, almost a third of us (32%) are tucking in to tubs of ice cream at home multiple times each week.
But with so many brands on the market, from home-grown ice creams to new luxury international ones, which offer the best taste and represent true value for money?
As part of our mission to inform consumers of the best NZ has to offer, Canstar Blue canvassed the opinions of 2021 New Zealanders who had bought and eaten ice cream tubs from a supermarket or grocer in the past three months, across a range of categories, to measure and track their satisfaction.
To decide which ice cream manufacturer offers the best level of customer satisfaction, each was rated across the following categories:
Coming out on top is Much Moore ice cream. The family owned New Zealand ice cream company beat out the international competition with their delicious frozen treats, which they’ve been making for over 30 years.
While taste, unsurprisingly, is the top driver of satisfaction for those in our survey, value for money and variety of range also rate highly. Overall, the main drivers of satisfaction:
Drivers of satisfaction | % |
Taste | 46% |
Value for Money | 29% |
Variety/Range | 17% |
Packaging Appeal | 8% |
As you can see from our above infographic, berry is the top flavour of ice cream in our survey, closely followed by chocolate and vanilla.
But new exotic flavours are catching up, with cookies and cream, and salted caramel, encroaching on traditional Kiwi hokey pokey:
Favourite flavour | % |
Berry (strawberry, raspberry or boysenberry) | 15% |
Chocolate | 13% |
Vanilla | 11% |
Hokey Pokey | 10% |
Cookies & Cream | 9% |
Salted Caramel | 9% |
Goody Goody Gum Drops | 6% |
Mint Chocolate Chip | 5% |
Rum and Raisin | 5% |
Orange Chocolate Chip | 4% |
Neapolitan | 3% |
Other | 10% |
But regardless of which flavour you lap up, our research uncovered the true flavour of many of our ice-cream experiences. Nearly half of our respondents say ice cream always brings back good memories, of childhood, family and long-hot Kiwi summers.
So if you’re looking for a sweet-as way to cool down this summer, why not get much more satisfaction from your choice of ice cream with the winner Canstar’s award for Most Satisfied Customers | Ice Cream … Much Moore.
Every day | 3% |
Few times a week | 32% |
Few times a month | 49% |
Less often | 16% |
I try different brands/flavours | 64% |
I choose brands on special offer | 54% |
My favourite brand is expensive, so I only buy it as a treat | 28% |
It tastes better | 69% |
I think it’s healthier | 52% |
Dietary requirements | 10% |
It’s healthier | 32% |
I’m lactose intolerant | 15% |
I prefer the taste | 11% |
I’m vegan | 7% |
Natural ingredients | 69% |
Low sugar | 33% |
Canstar Blue surveyed 2615 New Zealand consumers across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers who had bought and eaten ice cream tubs from a supermarket or grocer in the past three months. In this case, 2021 New Zealanders.
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
Consumer News - March 20th
What is Clubcard?
Clubcard is a loyalty program offered by the supermarket chain New World. It allows customers to earn either Flybuys, New World Dollars or Airpoints Dollars when shopping instore and online.
Clubcard members are eligible …
– Read moreBest-Rated Meal Kits - March 11th
Do you know your soy milk from your flaxseed milk? Here is a guide to the different types of milk in your supermarket.
– Read moreBest-Rated BBQs - February 16th
What is Everyday Rewards?
Everyday Rewards is a loyalty program offered by the supermarket chain Woolworths. It allows customers to accumulate points on their purchases at Woolworths stores, when refueling at BP, using an ASB rewards …
Best-Rated BBQs - November 14th
What is a milk frother?
As the name suggests, a milk frother is a nifty gadget used to froth milk, typically to add to coffees and specialty drinks, such as frappés and even cocktails. It works …
Best-Rated Supermarkets - May 27th
Author: Michael Lund
Want to save money on groceries? Canstar has some great tips to provide relief at the check-out:
How to Save Money on Groceries
1. Make a weekly meal plan
One of the best ways to save …
– Read more